By Jeffrey A. Rendall
Voters repeatedly tried telling President Trump and Republicans to put the economy first
What do the voters really think?
Both parties act as though this is the million dollar question, the answer to which lies electoral immortality and perpetual keys to congressional majorities on Capitol Hill and the front door of the White House.
Further, both parties claim to care about the same things people value, and swear to do the voters’ bidding if given the opportunity to propose and pass laws to reflect the will of the citizenry. But time after time, the issue voters cite as most important to them is the economy. Citizens want to make their money go as far as possible.
It’s not rocket science. As “Rajin’ Cajun” James Carville used to preach to Big Bubba Bill Clinton, “It’s the economy, stupid.”
2026 was no different. The recently concluded disastrous Blue Wave had many inspirations, but none was stronger than Americans’ worries about the economy. If only Republicans had acknowledged the warning signs.
In an article titled, “Poll: GOP voters say the party isn’t focused enough on the economy”, Erin Doherty, Andrew Howard and Jessie Blaeser reported at Politico the day of the 2026 election:
“Republicans don’t think their party is focused enough on their biggest issue. The economy — and specifically the cost of living — is far and away voters’ top concern, and new results from The POLITICO Poll reveal a warning sign for the GOP just hours before polls close: There’s a stark disconnect between what Republican midterm voters want their party to focus on and what they say the party actually is focusing on.
“Nearly half of Americans — 47% — say cost of living and affordability are among the issues that matter most when they are deciding how to vote. That includes a 44% plurality of Republican midterm voters and 54% of Democratic midterm voters. The economy and jobs ranked second.
“But when asked which issues matter most to their party, a 39% plurality of Republican voters cited immigration and deportations as a top priority for the GOP. Just 23% said the party’s top priority was cost of living and affordability — a 21-point gap from the share who said it was a top voting concern.”
Before you say this information might have been more useful to President Donald Trump — and the rest of the Republican party – if presented with plenty of lag time before the disaster and therefore, grant them an opportunity to do something about it, astute political observers would point out that there was sufficient warning and Republicans blew it.
The warning signs were everywhere. Republicans, led by President Trump, ignored or dismissed them as “fake news” and media distortion rather than take a bite from a slice of humble pie and listen to what survey respondents told them in time to perhaps change course.
For months I’ve argued that Republicans needed to stop boasting that we have the “hottest country in the world” and realize that voter perceptions don’t match the spin of the political class. If only the average person would read a news tidbit and say to him/herself, “Oh, real incomes increased much faster under Trump than under Biden” and change attitudes accordingly. Republicans would have been set!
Was I akin to a fortuneteller or soothsayer for seeing that the elevated consumer prices would likely spell doom for Republicans in 2026?
Hardly. Living in Virginia, I saw what happened a year ago in the Commonwealth’s off-year elections when heinous hypocrite and programmed robotic liar Abigail Spanberger won by a landslide over her helpless Republican opponent in the governor’s race. Virginia’s other constitutional offices also went blue as did both houses of the legislature. Recall how, a year ago today, Republicans (led by former Governor Glenn Youngkin) were still in power.
My, how things change quickly. Spanberger and her aggressive and hungry Democrat colleagues wasted no time imposing their will on the citizens of Virginia in 2026, too. The same phenomenon happened in New Jersey and in New York City, where an avowed socialist promising government-run grocery stores won the mayoral election.
In other words, Democrats struck gold with the “affordability” meme in 2025 and it didn’t take much brain power to assume the same tactic could work swimmingly again this year with the so-called battlefield vastly expanded to all fifty states (including Virginia and New Jersey, in addition).
The Republican political brains’ excuses for not adapting to the new realities were many. They said, “The 2025 elections were conducted in blue states in a year with a Republican president in the White House… and Republicans never win in Virginia when a Republican is president.”
Or, “We chose weak candidates, or we would’ve won in South Carolina if Lindsey Graham hadn’t suddenly passed away.” Like Republicans would’ve retained those seats this year if the establishment pols had been on the ballot instead of the candidates conservative primary voters chose. It’s the same nonsense the “experts” spout every time a grassroots chosen conservative candidate loses an election. Remember Delaware? Missouri? Indiana? And/or Alabama (Roy Moore)?
Hindsight is 20-20, indeed, and this includes this year. Republicans added a sizable fundraising advantage and redistricting changes to the roster of reasons why they would defy history and the polls in order to retain their congressional majorities in 2026. Their hubris was legendary as Republican media backers said, time and again, that the public opinion poll numbers couldn’t possibly be correct.
All they needed to do was look around. Or dial up publications like Real Clear Politics or The Hill or Politico and take a hard look at the poll numbers, most specifically, the ones regarding the economy and what voters ranked as important.
Here’s guessing the pre-Trump Republican mouthpieces will return to their “Traditional conservatism and social issues caused the Republicans to lose” line of persuasion they’ve always used to employ whenever Republicans underperformed at the ballot box. The “experts” have already taken the chance to say “It was all about Trump” this time.
Make no mistake, President Trump and his tone-deaf messaging operation played a major role in this year’s drubbing. But as the “autopsies” continue and more and more outsiders contribute their opinions to “what went wrong”, it should be remembered Democrats didn’t win so impressively because they offered better solutions.
Democrats won because they weren’t Republicans. The realization for most Americans will hit early in 2027 when Democrats crawl over themselves to advance their notions of how America can fix itself which will almost certainly include some manner of tax hikes, kook-fringe environmental restrictions, non-stop investigations and congressional subpoenas that will almost turn Trump officials into sympathetic characters.
Americans will soon wonder, what happened to the Democrats’ promises on cost-of-living and “affordability”? Will Democrats concoct their own “stimulus package” full of tax increases and slush funds for Democrat backers and try to sell the legislation as a “must sign or else the poor will suffer” ultimatum for President Trump?
If the economy pulls out of the doldrums – if indeed the economy is less than stellar now (a debatable point) – it won’t be due to whatever big government interference Democrats have in mind to help people with dollars and cents.
Besides, why else would voters think the GOP didn’t pay sufficient attention to the economy this year? The answer is simple: the Iran War and President Trump’s penchant for personal vendettas (a.k.a., the Justice Department’s pursuit of his enemies, or score-settling), the public relations snafus over Canada tariffs, the “Gulf of America”, annexing Greenland and inconsistent messaging over Ukraine/Russia, among other public relations missteps.
Voters’ conclusion: Can Trump focus on anything? What about me? What about gas and food prices? Didn’t Trump promise to fix Joe Biden’s mess? Or did he just deepen the problem by trying to tackle everything at once, including mixing his foreign policy with his views on trade?
All along, it was obvious to many of us that the economy would dominate voters’ motivations at the ballot box this year. If Americans thought Republicans weren’t listening to their concerns, their natural inclination was to vote against the party in power. President Trump and congressional leaders were months late and many dollars short.
Let’s hope they’ll learn from 2026 and remember, “It’s the economy, stupid.” Republicans need to begin every speech/interview with it.
Jeff Rendall is editor and publisher of GolfintheUSA.com and has written about golf and politics for over a quarter of a century. A non-practicing attorney from California, he moved to the east coast three decades ago to pursue and combine his interests in all things American history and culture. Jeff has worked as an intern on Capitol Hill and in various capacities in grassroots organizing and conservative organizations and publications, including a nearly two-decade stint at ConservativeHQ.com. Column republishing or other inquiries: Rendall@msn.com .
